Performance driven FPGA design with an ASIC perspective

Andreas Ehliar

Still RelevantAdvanced

FPGA devices are an important component in many modern devices. This means that it is important that VLSI designers have a thorough knowledge of how to optimize designs for FPGAs. While the design flows for ASICs and FPGAs are similar, there are many differences as well due to the limitations inherent in FPGA devices. To be able to use an FPGA efficiently it is important to be aware of both the strengths and oweaknesses of FPGAs. If an FPGA design should be ported to an ASIC at a later stage it is also important to take this into account early in the design cycle so that the ASIC port will be efficient. This thesis investigates how to optimize a design for an FPGA through a number of case studies of important SoC components. One of these case studies discusses high speed processors and the tradeoffs that are necessary when constructing very high speed processors in FPGAs. The processor has a maximum clock frequency of 357~MHz in a Xilinx Virtex-4 devices of the fastest speedgrade, which is significantly higher than Xilinx' own processor in the same FPGA. Another case study investigates floating point datapaths and describes how a floating point adder and multiplier can be efficiently implemented in an FPGA. The final case study investigates Network-on-Chip architectures and how these can be optimized for FPGAs. The main focus is on packet switched architectures, but a circuit switched architecture optimized for FPGAs is also investigated. All of these case studies also contain information about potential pitfalls when porting designs optimized for an FPGA to an ASIC. The focus in this case is on systems where initial low volume production will be using FPGAs while still keeping the option open to port the design to an ASIC if the demand is high. This information will also be useful for designers who want to create IP cores that can be efficiently mapped to both FPGAs and ASICs. Finally, a framework is also presented which allows for the creation of custom backend tools for the Xilinx design flow. The framework is already useful for some tasks, but the main reason for including it is to inspire researchers and developers to use this powerful ability in their own design tools.

Summary

This PhD thesis investigates performance-driven FPGA design from an ASIC-aware viewpoint, showing how VLSI designers can optimize logic, datapaths and SoC components for FPGA fabrics. Through case studies— including high-speed processors— the author demonstrates techniques to achieve efficient FPGA implementations while preserving portability for future ASIC migration.

Key Takeaways

Identify FPGA-specific architectural trade-offs compared to ASICs to guide early design decisions.
Apply synthesis, placement and floorplanning techniques to improve timing, area, and resource utilization on FPGAs.
Optimize processor cores and SoC components for FPGA primitives such as LUTs, BRAMs and DSP slices.
Plan design practices that simplify and improve the efficiency of later ASIC porting.